Best Cat Food: How to Choose (Wet, Dry, Indoor and Senior)

Sylvester, a black and white cat, relaxing on a grey couch
In this guide
  1. How to choose a good cat food
  2. Wet or dry cat food?
  3. Cat food brands worth looking at
  4. How much should I feed my cat?
  5. Best cat food for indoor cats
  6. Best cat food for a sensitive stomach
  7. Best cat food for weight loss
  8. Best cat food for senior cats
  9. The best cheap cat food
  10. Marketing claims that matter less than you’d think
  11. How to switch cat foods
  12. FAQs
  13. Sources

The short answer: the best cat food is a complete and balanced food labelled for adult maintenance (or all life stages), made by a company that employs qualified nutritionists. It should be one your cat eats happily and you can afford to feed consistently. Wet, dry or a mix can all be healthy. What matters more is choosing the right formula for your cat (indoor, sensitive stomach, overweight or senior) and feeding the right amount.

What I feed my cat: When my cat was young, we tried a few brands, and Hill’s was the one that worked best for us. My cat Sylvester is on Hill’s today. That’s one household’s experience, so use the checks below to find what suits your cat. Ryan

How to choose a good cat food

1. Check the label for “complete and balanced”

On the back of the bag or can, find the small print that says the food is complete and balanced for adult maintenance or all life stages. In the US this is the AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement. According to the FDA, it means the food is meant to be fed as your cat’s sole diet. The Cornell Feline Health Center calls the nutrition label the best way to compare cat foods.

Watch out for products labelled complementary, supplemental or for intermittent feeding. Many broths, toppers and fancy pouches are treats, not a full diet. For an example, see is Fancy Feast good for cats?, where some ranges are complete and some are complementary.

2. Check who makes it

Vets often suggest asking the questions from the World Small Animal Veterinary Association’s nutrition guidelines:

  • Does the company employ a qualified nutritionist (a PhD animal nutritionist or a board-certified veterinary nutritionist)?
  • Who formulates the food, and is it tested in feeding trials?
  • What quality control does the company use?

A brand that can’t answer these clearly is a red flag. Big names aren’t automatically better, but the large, research-based manufacturers can usually answer all three.

3. Match the food to your cat

An indoor cat, a cat with a sensitive stomach, an overweight cat and a 14-year-old cat all have different needs. The sections below cover each one.

Wet or dry cat food?

Both can be healthy, as long as the food is complete and balanced. Cornell notes that some cats like canned food, some like dry, and some like a combination. It even suggests feeding two or three different foods for variety.

Feature Wet (canned or pouch) Dry (kibble)
Water At least 75% moisture, according to Cornell. A good source of water. Only 6 to 10% water, so your cat needs to drink more
Calories Fewer calories per bite, which can help cats that overeat Calorie-dense, so it’s easy to overfeed
Cost Generally the most expensive Relatively inexpensive
Convenience Spoils once opened. Refrigerate and use within a day or so. Can be left out and measured easily
Good for Cats that drink little, cats prone to urinary problems, weight control Budget, convenience, puzzle feeders

Many vets suggest a mix, such as wet food for meals and a measured amount of dry food in a puzzle feeder. Your cat gets the extra water from the wet food and the convenience of the dry.

Cat food brands worth looking at

These brands are widely available and made by large manufacturers that publicly state they employ nutritionists and research their foods. Each has complete and balanced adult ranges. Formulas change, so always check the label on the exact product you buy.

Your cat’s needs Ranges worth considering
Healthy adult cat Hill’s Science Diet Adult, Purina Pro Plan Adult, Royal Canin, Iams ProActive Health Adult (dry and wet)
Indoor cat Hill’s Science Diet Indoor, Royal Canin Indoor Adult, Purina ONE +Plus Indoor Advantage, Iams ProActive Health Indoor Weight & Hairball Care
Sensitive stomach Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin, Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin and Stomach, Royal Canin Digestive Care
Overweight cat Hill’s Science Diet Perfect Weight, Purina Pro Plan Weight Management. For real weight loss, ask your vet about a prescription weight-loss diet.
Senior cat (7+ or 11+) Hill’s Science Diet Adult 7+ or 11+, Purina Pro Plan senior formulas, Royal Canin Aging 12+
Tight budget Purina Cat Chow or Purina ONE (dry), Friskies or Fancy Feast (wet). Check for “complete and balanced”.

No single food is “the best” for every cat. A sound food that your cat eats well and stays healthy on (good energy, steady weight, a glossy coat, normal stools and no regular vomiting) is the best food for your cat. Once you find it, there’s no need to keep switching.

How much should I feed my cat?

Start with the feeding guide on the label, based on your cat’s ideal weight, not their current weight. Or use our free cat food calculator to work out your cat’s daily calories and turn them into cups, cans or grams. Then adjust based on body shape:

  • You should be able to feel the ribs easily under a thin layer of fat, and see a slight waist from above. Vets score body condition from 1 to 9, and 4 to 5 is ideal. The Pet Obesity Prevention body condition chart shows what each score looks like.
  • Weigh your cat every month or two. A kitchen or bathroom scale works: weigh yourself holding your cat, then subtract your own weight.
  • Count treats. Cornell suggests treats make up no more than 10 to 15% of your cat’s daily calories.

Cornell calls obesity the most common nutrition-related problem in cats. A cat that is just 1 kg (2 lb) overweight is carrying a lot of extra weight for its size.

Best cat food for indoor cats

Indoor cats usually move less, so they need fewer calories and are more likely to put on weight. “Indoor” formulas are typically a little lower in calories and often add fibre to help with hairballs. An indoor formula isn’t essential, though. Any complete and balanced adult food works, as long as you measure portions and keep your cat active with play. Wet food or a puzzle feeder also helps indoor cats eat more slowly.

Best cat food for a sensitive stomach

If your cat often vomits or has soft stools, a “sensitive stomach” formula can help. These are usually made to be easier to digest. Change foods gradually over 7 to 10 days, and remember that regular vomiting or diarrhoea always deserves a vet check first, because it’s often a medical problem rather than a food one. See why cats throw up and when to worry.

If your vet suspects a food allergy or intolerance, they will usually suggest a strict diet trial with a prescription hydrolysed or limited-ingredient food. Swapping between supermarket foods rarely gives a clear answer.

Best cat food for weight loss

Cutting back your cat’s normal food too much can leave them short of nutrients, and crash diets are dangerous for cats. A cat that suddenly eats very little can develop a serious liver condition. For a cat that needs to lose weight, ask your vet for a target weight and a plan. They’ll usually suggest a weight-control or prescription weight-loss food and a slow, steady rate of loss. More tips are in our guide to keeping your cat at a healthy weight.

Best cat food for senior cats

Many cats are fed a senior formula from around 7 to 11 years old. Senior foods are often designed to be easy to digest and sometimes have adjusted calories, and many older cats find wet food easier to eat. Older cats vary a lot, though: some put on weight, while others start losing it. Unexplained weight loss in an older cat is a reason to see the vet, because it’s an early sign of common conditions like kidney disease and hyperthyroidism. If your senior cat has a medical condition, your vet may recommend a prescription diet instead.

The best cheap cat food

Feeding well doesn’t have to be expensive. A complete and balanced budget food from a reputable manufacturer is a better choice than an expensive food that is only complementary or that your cat won’t eat. Ways to save:

  • Choose dry food as the base, and add some wet food if you can.
  • Buy bigger bags, if you can store them airtight.
  • Measure portions. Overfeeding wastes money and adds weight.
  • Compare price per day of feeding, not per bag or can.

Marketing claims that matter less than you’d think

  • “Grain-free.” There’s no good evidence that grain-free food is healthier for most cats. Cooked grains are digestible, and grain-free foods aren’t automatically lower in carbohydrates.
  • “Real meat first.” Ingredients are listed by weight before cooking, and fresh meat is mostly water, so this says little about the finished food.
  • “By-products.” These include organ meats that can be very nutritious. The label term alone doesn’t tell you anything about quality.
  • “Natural”, “holistic”, “human-grade”. These are mostly marketing terms that say nothing about whether the food is complete and balanced.

How to switch cat foods

Change over gradually across 7 to 10 days, mixing in a bit more of the new food each day: about a quarter new for a few days, then half, then three-quarters, then all new. If you see loose stools, go back a step for a few days. Our kitten food guide has a day-by-day changeover chart that works for adult cats too.

FAQs

Vets usually recommend complete and balanced foods from manufacturers that employ qualified nutritionists and run feeding trials. Hill’s, Purina (Pro Plan and ONE), Royal Canin and Iams are commonly recommended. The best choice depends on your cat’s age, weight and health, so ask your vet at your cat’s next check-up.

Is wet or dry food better for cats?

Neither is better for every cat. Wet food adds water and has fewer calories per bite, which suits cats that drink little or overeat. Dry food is cheaper and convenient. Many vets suggest a mix.

What is the best cat food for indoor cats?

Any complete and balanced adult food, fed in measured portions. Indoor formulas from brands like Hill’s, Royal Canin, Purina ONE and Iams are a little lower in calories and often help with hairballs.

What is the best food for a cat with a sensitive stomach?

A sensitive stomach formula, such as Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin or Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin and Stomach, introduced gradually. If vomiting or diarrhoea is regular, see your vet first, since it may be a medical problem.

What is the cheapest healthy cat food?

A complete and balanced dry food from a reputable manufacturer, such as Purina Cat Chow or Purina ONE, fed in measured portions. Check the label for “complete and balanced for adult maintenance”.

Should I feed my cat grain-free food?

Only if your vet recommends it for a specific reason. There’s no good evidence that grain-free food is healthier for most cats.

Sources

You might also like